Leaders gearing up for English language debate tonight after French joust

OTTAWA-Five federal party leaders are licking their wounds and prepping their zingers after an occasionally testy debate Wednesday that came a day ahead of the first and only one in English.

Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau, Conservative Leader Erin O’Toole, NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh, Bloc Quebecois Leader Yves-Francois Blanchet and Green party Leader Annamie Paul will reconvene at 9 p.m. ET Thursday for the third debate.

The parties sought to stake out positions and attack their opponents in the hours leading up to the leaders’ debate, with Liberal candidate Chrystia Freeland criticizing the Conservatives’ childcare plan as a “step backward” for women, children and the economy.

The Liberal government has inked five-year deals with eight provinces and two territories to pay for more child-care spaces and reduce child-care fees to an average of $10 per day by 2026. The total cost is estimated at $30 billion, and includes a deal to transfer $6 billion to Quebec, which already offers $8.50-per-day child care, to increase the number of spaces available.

The Tories have said they would honour those deals for the first year if elected to government, but then convert the existing child-care expense deduction into a refundable tax credit that would cover up to 75 per cent of child-care costs for low-income families.

A Conservative costing document says almost $27 billion of the $30 billion allocated by the Liberal government for the program would be cut, replaced by a tax credit that would cost almost the same amount but go directly to parents.

“Early learning and child care is an urgent economic issue,” said Freeland, who is running the Toronto riding of University-Rosedale. “All parents , and I’m going to be candid here, especially all mothers, understand this. Erin O’Toole clearly does not.”

The Conservatives, meanwhile, highlighted their promise to ban products made with forced and slave labour, specifically calling out China’s treatment of its Uyghur minority while portraying themselves as the best choice for those concerned about human rights abroad.

“For years, we’ve known Uyghur slave labour is being used by China’s Communist regime in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region to produce products like cotton, tomatoes, and solar panels for export,” O’Toole said in a statement.

“As prime minister, I won’t hesitate to act against this disgusting practice and ensure that the worst human rights offenders don’t profit from these abuses.”

Bloc Quebecois Leader Yves-Francois Blanchet on Thursday rejected the idea of being part of a coalition federal government after the election.

Blanchet said he would refuse any scenario that would see his party prop up a Liberal or Conservative minority government for any length of time in the House of Commons, and would instead support a minority government that would survive a full four-year mandate.

Before the English-language debate, Singh went shopping with his expecting wife at an Ottawa baby store on Thursday.

Several NDP candidates in the Toronto area have highlighted the party’s promise to establish a guaranteed livable income, starting with seniors and people living with a disability.

“This is absolutely essential,” said Alejandra Bravo, the candidate for Davenport. “This, coupled with our amazing commitments around affordable housing, which are tangible and doable, are going to make a significant difference to reduce the poverty in this country.”

This week’s French and English-language debates come as opinion polls suggest the Liberals and Conservatives are stuck in a tight two-way race, with the NDP and Bloc poised to determine which of the two main parties emerges victorious.

The five themes selected for Thursday night’s debate are affordability, climate, recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic, leadership and accountability, and reconciliation with Indigenous Peoples.

The topics discussed during Wednesday’s French-language event included health transfers to the provinces, childcare funding, climate and the COVID-19 pandemic as the politicians sought to sway francophones ahead of the election on Sept. 20.

Much of the back-and-forth Wednesday revolved around health care and how to pay for it. Moderator Patrice Roy pushed the politicians over whether they would hand over the extra $28 billion in annual funding requested by premiers.

On Thursday, Quebec Premier Francois Legault criticized Trudeau and Singh for wanting to introduce national standards in health care, saying they would appropriate provincial powers.

The premier also said he was pleased that the Conservatives, particularly over O’Toole’s plan to increase health transfers without conditions, but expressed concern that the Conservatives would cancel the $6-billion deal for daycare inked by the federal Liberals.

Freeland and fellow Liberal candidate Jean-Yves Duclos, who is running in the Quebec City riding of Quebec, defended the Trudeau government’s record in the province when asked about Legault’s comments. They said it has worked well with the province in the past, including in signing the $6-billion deal for more child care spaces.

“I have the most respect for Quebecers,” Freeland said. “And I trust them to listen carefully to what we are committing to in our platform to look carefully at what our government has done already.

And I trust them to make the right choice for themselves.”

The spiciest exchange during Wednesday’s debate concerned issues of Quebec identity and representation.

An animated Trudeau turned on Blanchet late in the debate, proclaiming he is also a “proud Quebecer” and that Blanchet does not have a monopoly on the province.

“You keep forgetting: I’m a Quebecer,” Trudeau said, his face flushed, while a small smile slid across Blanchet’s. “I have always been a Quebecer, I will always be a Quebecer.

“You have no right to consider me not a Quebecer.”

Blanchet conceded to reporters in English after the debate that it was “probably true” that Trudeau was as much a Quebecer as him.

“But in terms of institutions, this is the Assemblee nationale du Quebec which speaks for Quebec,” he said, referring to the French name for the provincial legislature, adding that Quebecers are “obviously not” a monolith.

Paul brought a personal touch to the federal debate, the first for the 11-month Green leader, noting her father’s death in a long-term care home during the pandemic’s second wave. She also said she sees Greens as “allies” to First Nations, citing her own experience as part of a diaspora robbed of its traditional culture.

Singh said he would “completely agree” that Indigenous languages should be recognized as official, going further than other leaders asked on the topic Wednesday.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 9, 2021.

-With files from Jacob Serebrin in Montreal, Allison Jones in Toronto and Lee Berthiaume in Ottawa.

Add Your Voice

Is there more to this story? We'd like to hear from you about this or any other stories you think we should know about. Contribute your voice on our contribute page.